Should You Read the Book or See the Movie First?

Buzzfeed recently posted a list of Sixteen Books To Read Before They Hit the Theaters this Year.  As readers, we accept this as the natural order of things.  To do otherwise would be as unfathomable as eating one’s desert before dinner.  And yet, I still find myself wondering, is reading a book before seeing the movie really a good idea?  Or, are we just setting ourselves up for disappointment by reading these books in advance?  Ask yourself, when is the last time you were satisfied with a movie adaptation?

Unfortunately, no matter how stellar the cast or celebrated the director, we almost always find fault with the movie.  We complain that the actors look nothing like the characters we imagined (i.e. Tom Cruise as Jack Reacher).  We lament the loss of stories and characters that are sacrificed in the interest of time (Tom Bombadil from Lord of the Rings ). Many times, these adaptations are excellent films.  Some even win awards.  And yet, we still feel the intangible absence of something we can’t quite put our finger on.  The truth is, cherished books live in a place in our imagination that is simply impossible to replicate in the real world.

Surprisingly, the reverse does not seem to hold true. Picking up a book after watching the movie version usually leads to enlightenment, not disappointment.  Waiting to read the book allows you to watch and enjoy the movie without the weight of your own expectations (i.e. book baggage).  But, there is a catch.  Your impressions of the characters and settings will not be your own.  They will belong to a movie studio. Who knows what beautiful and terrible images you might have conjured in your mind’s eye.  You will never know.

And so, we readers must make a choice.  Read the book first and spoil the movie, or watch the movie first and spoil the book.  Quite the dilemma.  And yet, ultimately, I find the choice an easy one.  After all, you never get a second chance to experience a book for the first time.  And I want that experience to last for days, not 2.5 hours.  Guess I’m in for a year of disappointment at the movie theater, because these books are just too good to pass up!

Books Coming Soon to a Theater Near You:

  

  

  

  

  

Upcoming Book Discussions @ the Library

Do you ever feel let down after you finish a book because you just had an amazing reading experience that no one else can appreciate?  Do you often wish you could share your thoughts about the characters or the story with people who actually know what you’re talking about?  If so, you should check out one of our many book clubs here at the Library.  Discover new books and authors while meeting others who enjoy reading as much as you do!

Book clubs meet regularly each month and you don’t need to sign up ahead of time.  Just stop by the Adult Services Desk at the Main Library to pick up copies of the books being discussed each month.  Books will be available to check out the month before each discussion.

Book Clubbers:
Meets the first Thursday of each month.

Thursday, February 6th @ 7pm (Harnish)

Weird Sisters
by Eleanor Brown

When three sisters gather to care for their mother we are treated to the hilarious and thought provoking complications of sisters who love each other fiercely but don’t like each other much.

 


Spine Crackers:
Meets the first Friday of each month.

Friday, February 7th @ 1:30 pm (Harnish)

The Flight of Gemma Hardy
by Margot Livesey

In this modern retelling of Jan Eyre, Gemma Hardy, a brilliant and determined young woman, accepts a position as an au pair on the remote Orkney Islands, where she faces her biggest challenge yet.

 

 

Nite Readers:
Meets the third Thursday of each month.

Thursday, January 16th @ 7pm (Harnish)

Isaac’s Storm
by Erik Larson

Erik Larson, author of Devil in the White City, tells the fascinating story of another up and coming city – Galvaston, Texas. At the turn of the century, Galvaston was poised to become the New York of the Gulf until the deadliest hurricane in our nation’s history destroys everything.

 

Thursday, February 20th @ 7pm (Harnish)

Beneath a Marble Sky
by John Shors

A novel of the Taj Mahal.  the story of the princess whose tomb became a world of wonder.

 

 


Bookalicious:
A new book club for adults who love to read Young Adult literature.
Meets the second Monday of the the month.

Monday, January 13th @ 7pm (Harnish)

The Future of Us
by Jay Asher & Carolyn Mackler

Set in the year 1996, best friends Josh and Emma discover their future selves on a mysterious web site called Facebook. Does knowing the future change it?

 

 

Classics Book Club:
Meets the third Wednesday of the month.

Wednesday, January 15th @ 7pm (Harnish)

The Ambassadors
by Henry James

Lambert Strether has one job. Bring Mrs. Newsome’s wayward son Chad back home to America from Paris. Yet, as Lambert is seduced by the city and the mysterious Madame de Vionnet, he may never want to leave himself.

 


Wednesday, February 19th @ 7 pm (Harnish)

Canterbury Tales
by Geoffrey Chaucer

On a pilgrimage to the shrine of Thomas à Becket in Canterbury, travelers entertain themselves by telling stories ranging in genre from fable, to romance, to bawdy comedy in 13th century England.

 

 

 

January LibraryReads List Announced

Visit LibraryReads for more information about how this list was created, and to view favorites from previous months!

The Dead in Their Vaulted Arches:
A Flavia de Luce Novel
by Alan Bradley

“Flavia de Luce is still on the loose! This time, the almost-twelve-year-old prodigy explores some tantalizing mysteries involving her own family. Flavia uncovers surprising secrets about the characters we know and love and meets some fascinating new people, including a precocious distant cousin. You’ll enjoy seeing new depths in Flavia–this novel takes the series in an exciting direction.”

–  Nancy Russell, Columbus Metropolitan Library, Columbus, OH

A Star for Mrs. Blake: A Novel
by April Smith

“A little-known slice of American history receives meticulous, elegant treatment in this compelling novel about a group of mothers who travel to post-WWI Europe to visit the graves of their fallen soldier-sons. Cora Blake, grieving the loss of her only child, pulls the group together to provide support on their difficult pilgrimage. Sure to be a sleeper hit with book groups looking for heart-tugging history.”

– Kaite Stover, Kansas City Public Library, Kansas City, MO

Lost Lake: A Novel
by Sarah Addison Allen

“I was thrilled to find out that Sarah Addison Allen had a new book out, and it did not disappoint. Allen’s trademark magic is woven throughout the story and can be found in the lake, the town, and the people, but at its heart, this story is about finding home—something we can all relate to.”

– Ally Watkins, Central MS Regional Library System, Pearl, MS

The Days of Anna Madrigal: A Novel
by Armistead Maupin

“So good to see all these beloved characters again! And we finally get the true story of Anna Madrigal. If you’re either a fan of the Tales of the City series, Burning Man or both, this is a fun Sunday-afternoon kind of book.”

Jenne Bergstrom, San Diego County Library, San Diego, CA

A Highly Unlikely Scenario, or a Neetsa Pizza Employee’s Guide to Saving the World: A Novel
by Rachel Cantor

“Leonard works for Neetsa Pizza, a Pythagorean pizza chain, in the near-ish future. His job is to take calls, listen to complaints and help his customers achieve maximum pizza happiness. His employee manual gives him an answer for every scenario–until he gets a call from Marco, who seems to be calling from another time or space. Think of Terry Pratchett crossed with Douglas Adams.”

– Jane Jorgenson, Madison Public Library, Madison, WI

The Wind Is Not a River: A Novel
by Brian Payton

“A tender love story about a reporter stranded during World War II on one of the Aleutian Islands, and his feisty wife, who travels to find him. The geographical and historical setting of American warfare in the North Pacific, little known to most, is very intriguing. Readers will fall in love with the main characters’ fierce determination to survive and love against all odds.”

– Paulette Brooks, Elm Grove Public Library, Elm Grove, WI

Orfeo: A Novel
by Richard Powers

“Experimental music and genetic engineering? Heady stuff indeed, but what is most remarkable about this thought-provoking journey is how intensely it makes you feel about human creativity, experience, and the enigmatic fugitive Peter Els, whose flight from an uncomprehending world anchors the narrative. A perfect introduction to this brilliant but sometimes forbidding author.”

– David Wright, Seattle Public Library, Seattle, WA

The Kept: A Novel
by James Scott

“Scott has written a haunting novel about two characters who are tormented by regret and guilt and who do all the wrong things to find redemption. Beautiful writing and unforgettable characters mark this first novel that has been compared to the work of Cormac McCarthy and Michael Ondaatje.”

– Alison Kastner, Multnomah County Library, Portland, OR

Little Failure: A Memoir
by Gary Shteyngart

“Little Failure is the marvelous tale of the Shteyngart family’s journey from Leningrad to Queens in the 1970s. Gary Shteyngart captures an amazing snapshot of that time in history, and this engaging memoir is suffused with conflict, love, and a lot of hilarity.”

– Laura Scott, Park Ridge Public Library, Park Ridge, IL

The First True Lie: A Novel
by Marina Mander

“An unusual, well-written story told by a young boy who lives with his talented, but troubled mother in a city apartment in Italy. One morning, Luca finds his mother dead, and his worst fears paralyze him. How long can he hide the truth from his teachers and classmates? Luca uses what he loves most, words, to reach a place where he can finally open the door to others. An excellent reading group selection.”

– Margaret Donovan, Cary Memorial Library, Lexington, MA